Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Philadelphia Freedom
Probably just semantics but to me the picks each team had means the picks that they were alloted to start with. This would be as opposed to the picks that they ended up with.
Not that it matters much but if I had traded my four picks for Andre Johnson, Clinton Portis, and Dante Culpepper I think I would have done well with those picks. However, it sounds like you are saying that this would deserve a poor grade.
|
I guess I was saying what I said just for simplicity sake. It's hard enough for me to look at the lists and grade each of the picks based on their value and place taken, but to throw in the trades makes it far more than my little brain can comprehend.
If you are including players teams traded away for, then logically you also have to take those players away from the grade of the team that traded them away. That just makes it too much for me to sift through. If someone else can do them, more power to them. However, I was just saying that I agreed with the grades for the most part, not even bringing the trades into question, as I was grading the drafts based purely on the quality of the picks, not the total quality of talent brought into each team through the draft.
Not necessarily semantics, just a different way of doing things.